RunCabin Blog · For working contractors

I got an email saying my business won an award. Is it a scam?

November 14, 2026 · 7 min read

The subject line says "Congratulations." Your painting company, eighteen months old, has been named a Best of 2026 winner for your city. There is a press release already written with your business name in it, a picture of a glass plaque, and a link to "claim your award." You did not enter anything. You have never heard of the group that picked you. And for about ten seconds it still feels good.

Short answer: if you never entered, nobody can tell you who voted, and the email ends with something to buy, it is a vanity award. You did not win anything. You were offered a plaque. The Better Business Bureau has warned owners about these for years. Here is how they work, five questions that sort a real award from a bought one, what to do with the email, and what is honest to put on your website instead.

How a vanity award works

The BBB describes vanity awards as "illegitimate awards designed to deceive and extract money from unsuspecting businesses." The pattern barely changes from year to year:

  1. A list, not a judge. Your business name, city and trade are pulled from a public source: your state license record, your new LLC filing, your Google listing. Every business in the list "wins."
  2. An official-sounding name. The award is named after your town and your trade, or it sounds one word away from a real local award that people do know.
  3. A press release to make it feel finished. The email often includes a ready-made announcement so the award looks like it has already happened.
  4. The bill. The award is free. The plaque, the crystal trophy, the window sticker, the "digital badge" and the "media package" are not. The BBB puts the usual ask at "a couple of hundred dollars."

One reported example: in 2023, CBS Boston told the story of Kevin Richard, who builds sheds and porches in Cambridge, Massachusetts. He got an email naming him "Best Shed Maker of Cambridge." The sender had a generic name and no website. The offer was $150 for a plaque to display, or $1,500 for a media package. He did not pay, and he reported it to the BBB. That is one owner's story, not a statistic, but it is the template.

The same piece quoted BBB New England's Paula Fleming: "We all seek recognition, and unfortunately people have been scammed by this for many years."

If this email arrived a few weeks after you got licensed or filed your LLC, that is not a coincidence. New filings are public, and a new owner's inbox fills up fast: award emails, SEO sales calls, and domain renewal letters that look like bills. They all work from the same lists.

Two kinds of harm, and one is worse

Most vanity awards are a bad purchase, not a robbery. You pay, and a plaque really does show up. It just means nothing, because everyone who paid got one.

The worse kind is not selling a plaque at all. The BBB warns that some of these emails exist to collect card and bank details, and its advice is blunt: do not click suspicious links. An email you cannot trace, with a link you are told to click and a form asking for payment details, should be treated like any other phishing email, whatever it says you won.

Five questions that sort real from bought

There are real awards. A local newspaper's readers' choice vote is real. So is a chamber of commerce small-business award, or an honor from your trade association. The BBB says "most legitimate awards don't require a fee," and Fleming added a fair caveat: "There are legitimate awards out there, and some do have a small fee." So a fee alone does not settle it. These five questions do.

  1. Did I enter, or do I know who nominated me? The BBB's first tip is to ask how you were nominated. A real award can tell you. "Our research team selected you" is not an answer.
  2. Who runs it, and can I find them? A real award has a named organization, a street address, a phone number someone answers, and past winners you can look up. Search the award name with the word "scam," and look up the organization's BBB Business Profile.
  3. How are winners picked? Votes, judges, entry forms, site visits, a customer survey. Something. The BBB lists "awards that require few qualifications" as a red flag. If the only qualification is having an email address, it is a mailing list.
  4. Does the award still exist if I pay nothing? With a real award, your name is on the winners list whether or not you buy the frame. If paying is the only way the award shows up anywhere, the plaque is the product.
  5. Would a customer in my town recognize the name? This is the one that matters for business. An award only helps if the homeowner reading it has heard of who gave it.

If the email fails the first three, you have your answer.

What to do with the email

You do not owe the sender a reply, and nothing happens if you ignore it. There is no deadline on an award you did not enter.

Can I just buy the plaque and call us "award-winning"?

Buying a plaque is not illegal. Advertising with it is where the trouble starts.

The FTC's Endorsement Guides treat the names and seals of organizations as endorsements, and the basic rule for endorsements is that they have to be honest and not misleading. A badge on your website tells a homeowner that somebody independent looked at your work and judged it. If nobody did, and the badge was simply sold to you, that is the kind of claim those rules are aimed at. Many states also have their own rules about what a contractor may say in advertising. This is general information, not legal advice. If you are unsure about a specific badge, your state licensing board or a local attorney can tell you.

There is a plainer reason too. Homeowners search things. A customer who looks up "Best of Springfield Painters Award" and finds a page of scam warnings now knows something about you that no plaque can fix. The same goes for a competitor who wants to make you look bad in a bid.

And it does not solve the real problem. Owners buy these because they are new and want to look established. But as one HVAC owner put it on a trade forum, "a website alone isn't enough - Why would I choose you to work on my unit?" A bought award does not answer that question. Proof does.

What to show on your website instead

Everything on this list costs less than the plaque, and a customer can check every item:

If you won a real award, show it properly

When you do win one, do not just paste in a badge image. Write it out the way a customer can check:

A real award with a name and a year, next to your license number and a handful of real reviews, is a strong block of proof. A wall of badges nobody recognizes is weaker than no badges at all.

Where RunCabin fits

We build websites for local service businesses, and the proof block above is what we put on them: your license, your insurance, your real reviews, photos of your own jobs, and any award you actually won, written with who gave it and the year. We write each site to your state's advertising rules for your industry, which is one reason we would rather print a license number than a seal nobody can verify.

You answer our questionnaire, we build the site with AI, and a web developer finishes every page. You'll see your first version within 24 hours of sending your answers and photos. It starts at $499 to build, then $39.99 a month for hosting, or $479.88 a year. There is no long contract, you can cancel the hosting anytime, and there are no lead fees. We will never email you to say you won something.

Proof your customers can check

Your license, your reviews, your real jobs, on your own domain. Answer our questionnaire and we build the site with AI, then a web developer finishes every page. Starting at $499 to build, then $39.99 a month.

Start our planner →

Related reading: why you get so many website and SEO sales calls · the domain expiring letter · someone is threatening fake reviews unless I pay · is BBB accreditation worth it