RunCabin Blog · Before you sign
Someone offered to rent me a website that already ranks. Should I?
November 5, 2026 · 8 min read
Short answer: it can be a decent lead source, but it is not a website, and you should never treat it as one. A rented site works only while you pay, the customers meet a name that is not yours, and the phone number they save belongs to someone else. If the numbers work for your trade, rent it for the calls, and build your own site at the same time so you are not starting from zero the day the deal ends.
The pitch usually arrives as a cold email, a text or a call: "I have a site sitting on page one for roofing in your town. The calls are coming in and I need someone to send them to. Want them?" Here is what that offer actually is, what you get and what you do not, and the questions that separate a fair deal from a bad one.
What "rank and rent" means
Rank and rent is a business model from the search-marketing world. A marketer registers a generic domain, usually a town plus a trade, something in the shape of "springfieldgutterpros" or "countyline-tree-service". They build a simple site, write pages for each service and nearby town, and work it up Google's local results. Once it starts producing calls, they rent it to one local business.
The renter is you. You get the calls and form submissions the site produces. The marketer gets paid, either a flat monthly fee or a price per lead, and keeps everything else: the domain, the site, the phone number, the rankings and any reviews or links the site has collected. Courses and side-hustle blogs teach this model openly, which is why so many of these offers are landing in contractors' inboxes.
None of that is a scam on its face. Some operators run honest, exclusive sites that send one business real calls. But the structure matters more than the pitch, because it decides who holds the asset when the arrangement ends.
Rented leads vs your own website
| Rented ranking site | Your own website | |
|---|---|---|
| Whose name the customer sees | The site's generic brand | Yours |
| Who owns the domain | The marketer | You |
| Who owns the phone number | Usually the marketer (a tracking number) | You |
| When you stop paying | Calls stop, and can be sent to a competitor | The site keeps working as long as hosting is paid, and the domain stays yours |
| Reviews and links it earns | Stay with the site | Stay with your business |
| Who decides what it says | The marketer | You |
The left column is the same shape as paying Angi or Thumbtack for leads, with one difference that helps you: a rented site is usually exclusive to one business, so you are not racing other pros to the same homeowner. Owners who have paid per lead know that race well. One Angi pro wrote in a BBB complaint that leads were promised to go to "no more than three to five contractors ... This representation has proven to be inaccurate," and that the customer was "contacted by nearly ten different companies." That is one owner's complaint, not a statistic, but it is why exclusivity is the main selling point in these pitches.
When renting can make sense
- One job is worth a lot. Roof replacements, tree removal, foundation work, water damage and full repaints can cover a month of rent with a single closed job. Trades where an average ticket is small have a much harder time making the math work.
- You have capacity right now. If you have a crew sitting idle, extra calls this month matter more than an asset you will own next year.
- The calls are verifiably real and exclusive. You can hear recordings, see where the calls come from, and confirm nobody else is getting them.
- There is no long contract. Month to month means you can stop the day it stops paying for itself.
A simple test before you agree: take your average job value, multiply by how many of these calls you realistically close, and compare that to the monthly price. Use your own close rate, not the one in the pitch.
The catches nobody puts in the pitch
The phone number is theirs
Most rented sites use a call-tracking number the marketer controls, so they can count calls and prove the site is working. That is fine while you are the renter. The day you stop, they can forward that number to the next roofer in town. Every customer who saved it in their phone, kept a magnet with it on the fridge, or wrote it on a referral for a neighbor now reaches your competitor. Ask in writing whether you can port the number to yourself when you leave. If the answer is no, assume every repeat customer from that site is on loan.
The customer is not sure who you are
A homeowner who called "Springfield Gutter Pros" and then gets a truck with your name on it may be fine with that, or may be confused. Either way, they are not building a memory of your business. Repeat work and referrals, the cheapest jobs you will ever get, go back to the brand they remember. If that brand is the rented site, the referral is too.
Rankings move
Nobody can promise a position on Google, and that includes whoever owns a rented site. A search update or a new competitor can drop a page from the top of the results to the second page, and the calls go with it. If you have spent the past year relying on the rented site, you find out how much on the day it dips.
Watch what it says in your name
A rented site advertises the work you do, so check what it says about licensing, insurance, warranties and service areas. Many states regulate how contractors advertise, and some require a license number on ads. A site that promises a warranty you do not offer, or names towns you do not serve, sends you calls you have to disappoint. Ask to read every page before your number goes on it.
Ask about the Google listing
Some rented sites come with a Google Business Profile under the site's generic name. Google's Business Profile guidelines list lead generation companies among the businesses that are not eligible for a profile, and a listing with no real business behind it can be suspended. If the offer depends on a Google listing, ask whose business it represents. Your own Business Profile getting suspended is painful enough without staking your calls on someone else's.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Are the leads exclusive to my business, in writing?
- Is it a flat monthly fee or a price per lead, and what counts as a lead (a 10-second hang-up, a wrong number, a solicitor)?
- Can I hear call recordings and see form submissions?
- Is there a minimum term or a cancellation fee?
- Who owns the phone number, and can I port it when I leave?
- What happens to the site and the number the day I stop? Will it be rented to a competitor?
- Can I read and approve every page before it goes out with my number on it?
- Is there a Google Business Profile attached, and whose business is it under?
- Do I have the option to buy the domain, and at what price?
An operator who answers all of these clearly, and puts the answers in the agreement, is running a real business. One who gets vague about the phone number or the exit is telling you who the arrangement is built for.
Do both: rent the calls, own the asset
If a rented site pencils out, the best version of it is a short-term boost on top of something you own. Your own website under your own name is where everything you earn piles up: the reviews you link to it, the job photos, the pages about the towns you actually serve, and the phone number on your truck and your yard signs. It is also what customers check before they call you back. When the rented site goes quiet, your own site is still there.
A few habits make the rented calls build your own business instead of someone else's:
- Give every customer from the rented site your own card, your own number and your own website address, on the first visit.
- Ask them for a Google review on your profile, not the site's.
- Put them in your own customer list so maintenance reminders and seasonal offers come from you.
- Keep a simple tally of how many rented calls turn into jobs, so you know the real cost per job when renewal time comes.
If you are new and have nothing yet, start with your own Google Business Profile and a website, then decide whether a rented site is worth adding. If you are already burned out on paying per lead, a rented site is a variation on the same arrangement, so compare it honestly before you sign up for another one.
Where RunCabin fits
RunCabin builds the half of this you get to keep: a website for your own business, under your own name, on your own domain. You answer our questionnaire, we build the site with AI, and a web developer finishes every page with your services, your towns, your license number and photos of your actual jobs. You see a first version within 24 hours of sending your answers and photos. Your phone number is on every page, and the quote form sends every inquiry, photos included, straight to your inbox with no lead fees.
It starts at $499 to build, then $39.99 a month for hosting (or $479.88 a year), with no long contract. Optional tools are priced in the questionnaire, and you see the total before you pay. When you add a service or a town, you ask and the site gets updated. And if you ever cancel, your domain is yours.
Own the site the calls come back to
Answer our questionnaire and we build your site - your name, your number, your domain. It's built with AI and finished by a web developer. Starting at $499 to build, then $39.99 a month.
Start our planner →Related reading: do I need my own website if I get leads from Angi or Thumbtack? · should I put a call tracking number on my website?